Locate the decision independently, match its identifiers, read the full text, trace every quotation, and document what the decision does and does not establish.
1. Capture the exact claim#
Save the decision number, chamber, date, quoted passage, and the conclusion the AI attached to it. Missing identifiers are a warning, not an invitation to guess.
2. Find an authoritative or traceable source#
Search independently using the stated identifiers and distinctive phrases. Prefer an official publication where available; otherwise record the repository and retrieval date.
3. Match identity and text#
- Court and chamber
- Docket and decision numbers
- Decision date
- Parties or anonymized factual pattern
- Quoted passage in its surrounding context
4. Assess legal fit#
A real decision can still be factually distinguishable, superseded, exceptional, or unrelated to the proposed conclusion.
Identify the issue, material facts, reasoning, holding, procedural posture, and any later authority before relying on the citation.
5. Record the verification trail#
- Stable source or saved artifact
- Identifiers and access date
- Exact supporting passage
- Reason the passage is relevant
- Contrary or limiting authority
- Reviewer and review date when the workflow requires one
