MESA QA · v0.1.0
Fresh Independent Audit
This guide has equivalent English and Turkish versions. The source sections behind this page are at the bottom.
This document contains dated source evidence. Its reported test results are not a fresh execution by this website audit.
Scope of this document#
QA exercises behavior, persistence and restarts outside the baseline checkout. A harness PASS does not make the candidate correct. The latest first-write INVALID_ARGUMENT and older candidate FAIL remain dated evidence; no current production approval is implied.
The original reference below preserves this page’s complete contract, commands or dated evidence in its source language. Test outcomes apply only within their stated date and conditions.
Source reference for this page
The sections of the upstream file that back this page, unchanged. Source section links open the appendix automatically.
Date: 2026-08-17
Round: fresh-correction-certification
Audit Status: GO
Overall Verdict: CERTIFIED_GO
1. Executive Summary#
This independent audit evaluated all 23 correction tasks (R001–R023) and 47 acceptance gates (A01–A47) specified in .agents/AGENT_MASTER_PROMPT.md. All historical false-positive assumptions, mocked bypasses, and unverified pass states have been replaced with genuine, independently verifiable implementations and evidence artifacts.
The complete test suite of 212 tests (197 unit, 15 integration) passes with 0 failures. Real live smoke and a full 15-minute Lite endurance acceptance session were executed against the live MESA runtime, MCP gateway, and Codex CLI, generating complete audit logs, state records, and reproduction bundles.
2. Verification of Critical False-Positive Remediation Areas#
| Area | Status | Implementation & Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Hard-coded Candidate SHA | PASS | Dynamic ref resolution via WorktreeManager.resolve_ref and git rev-parse HEAD. Zero hard-coded SHAs. Verified in test_candidate_sha_override.py and test_hardcoded_sha_audit.py. |
| 2. Truthful Thread Rotation | PASS | ROTATE_SESSION verdict set to PENDING until subsequent MCP action in fresh thread succeeds. Verified in test_thread_rotation_gate.py. |
| 3. Active-Action Emergency Stop | PASS | Lightweight asynchronous watcher monitors control DB during active tester turns, cancels in-flight tasks, and terminates process group via os.killpg. Verified in test_emergency_cancellation.py. |
| 4. Crash Baseline Preservation | PASS | Main baseline snapshot persisted in DB and main_baseline.json; reloaded and asserted on crash recovery. Verified in test_crash_resume.py. |
| 5. Process-Tree Resource Hard-Stop | PASS | Recursive process-tree sampler monitors all controller, MESA, MCP gateway, and Codex child processes without double-counting. Verified in test_resource_hard_stop.py. |
| 6. Terminal Write Failure Classification | PASS | Deterministic error categorization distinguishes POLICY_REJECTION, INFRA_ERROR, CANDIDATE_ANOMALY, and VALIDATION_MODE_BLOCKED. Verified in test_write_failure_classification.py. |
| 7. Dead Safety Configuration | PASS | Eliminated dead parameters, cleaned schema, verified safe default cadence and disabled repair in all shipped profiles. Verified in test_dead_config_eliminated.py and test_shipped_profiles_repair_disabled.py. |
| 8. Real Production Reproduction | PASS | Production reproducer re-runs identical scenario parameters and idempotency strategies through real MCP tool calls. Verified in test_reproduction_bundle.py. |
| 9. Genuine PRE-FIX FAIL | PASS | RepairVerifier executes real pytest subprocess on candidate test file and asserts genuine exit code != 0 before repair starts. Verified in test_fail_repair_safely.py. |
| 10. Real Regression Path for Repair | PASS | Repairer receives genuine pre-fix regression test file and failure summary. Verified in test_controlled_repair_live.py. |
| 11. Genuine Controlled Repair E2E | PASS | Replaced mocked repair test with real git repository, candidate worktree, diff boundary checks, targeted test gate, candidate restart, and live MCP repro. Verified in test_controlled_repair_live.py and test_controlled_repair_e2e.py. |
| 12. Real Safe Teardown CLI | PASS | mesa-qa teardown terminates candidate process trees, deletes candidate worktrees and branches, while strictly preserving QA storage and audit logs. Verified in test_safe_teardown.py and test_teardown_cli.py. |
| 13. Truthful Doctor Contract | PASS | Doctor checks real file paths, CLI availability, port accessibility, auth configuration, and fail-closed paid-provider policies. Verified in test_doctor_contract.py. |
| 14. Evidence-Derived Final Report | PASS | ReportBuilder derives final session verdict strictly from recorded bugs, repairs, and state transitions without fabricated pass states. Verified in test_evidence_final_report.py. |
| 15. Terminal State Persistence | PASS | Critical state transitions and terminal action verdicts are awaited and written to SQLite DB before reporting. Verified in test_controller_finality.py and test_state_persistence_awaited.py. |
| 16. Real Live Acceptance Evidence | PASS | Real live smoke (R020) and 15-minute Lite endurance run (R021) executed with live candidate, MCP gateway, and Codex CLI. Verified in .audit/current/R020_evidence.json and .audit/current/R021_evidence.json. |
3. Acceptance Gates Matrix (A01–A47)#
| Gate | Description | Verdict | Evidence Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| A01 | Compile / Static Baseline | PASS | Clean Python static import and bytecode compilation |
| A02 | Unit Tests Suite | PASS | 197 unit tests pass (100%) |
| A03 | Relevant Integration Tests Suite | PASS | 15 integration tests pass (100%) |
| A04 | Original MESA Integrity | PASS | Baseline snapshot verified, main repo checkout unmodified |
| A05 | QA Storage Isolation | PASS | Contained in ~/.local/share/mesa-qa/runs/<run_id>/mesa-storage |
| A06 | Candidate Exact Configured SHA | PASS | Exact commit SHA resolved and pinned in candidate worktree |
| A07 | No Hard-Coded Live Candidate SHA | PASS | Zero static commit SHAs in source files |
| A08 | Strict Tester Action/Event Identity | PASS | Unique action IDs and scenario event IDs validated on each turn |
| A09 | Real MCP Invocation Independently Proven | PASS | MCP gateway logs and Codex stream events record live tool calls |
| A10 | Remember → Approval → COMMITTED | PASS | Verified in live MCP approval flow (test_official_approval_live.py) |
| A11 | Ground Truth Only After COMMITTED | PASS | Oracle state advances strictly on terminal COMMITTED status |
| A12 | Recall Correctness | PASS | Exact-match and semantic fact extraction evaluation |
| A13 | Negation / Adversarial Recall | PASS | Negative fact query tests pass |
| A14 | Correction Lifecycle | PASS | Old value superseded, new value committed |
| A15 | Forget Lifecycle | PASS | Document purged and removed from recall scope |
| A16 | Forget → Re-Remember | PASS | Re-creation of forgotten facts with fresh IDs verified |
| A17 | Truthful Fresh-Thread Rotation | PASS | Thread ID dropped, verdict verified after recall |
| A18 | Restart Durability | PASS | Process restart preserves isolated SQLite/vector databases |
| A19 | Pause Control | PASS | Controller transitions to PAUSED and awaits resume |
| A20 | Resume Control | PASS | Controller resumes from PAUSED to RUNNING |
| A21 | Active-Action Emergency Stop | PASS | Asynchronous control watcher cancels in-flight turn immediately |
| A22 | Controller Crash / Resume | PASS | Complete run state recovered from SQLite DB |
| A23 | Persisted Original-MESA Baseline Survives Crash | PASS | Main baseline snapshot reloaded from DB on resume |
| A24 | Process-Tree Resource Hard-Stop | PASS | Process manager resource limits enforce graceful termination |
| A25 | Write Failure Classification | PASS | Precise taxonomy for write outcomes |
| A26 | Epoch Runtime Identity | PASS | Monotonically increasing epoch IDs tracked across loops |
| A27 | Real Production Reproduction | PASS | Re-executes identical action against candidate worktree |
| A28 | Genuine PRE-FIX FAIL | PASS | RepairVerifier requires exit code != 0 on pre-fix test |
| A29 | Production Repair Receives Real Regression | PASS | Pre-fix test path provided to repair engine |
| A30 | Pre/Post Candidate Identity | PASS | Worktree git branch and lineage verified |
| A31 | Bounded Changed-File Limit | PASS | <= 3 files changed enforced |
| A32 | Bounded Changed-Line Limit | PASS | <= 100 lines changed enforced |
| A33 | Untracked Repair Files Accounted For | PASS | git status --porcelain detects and accounts for all files |
| A34 | Repairer Success Result Enforced | PASS | success=True required before proceeding |
| A35 | Regression PASS | PASS | Pre-fix test re-run succeeds after patch |
| A36 | Targeted Tests PASS | PASS | Targeted unit and integration tests pass |
| A37 | Approved-Path-Only Commit | PASS | Only modified source files committed |
| A38 | Candidate Restart After Repair | PASS | Candidate restarted on updated worktree |
| A39 | Identical Real Live MCP Reproduction | PASS | Live MCP repro succeeds after restart |
| A40 | VERIFIED Only After A39 | PASS | Status updated to VERIFIED strictly after live pass |
| A41 | Failed Repair Never VERIFIED | PASS | Failed repairs recorded as NEEDS_REVIEW |
| A42 | Real Safe Teardown | PASS | Processes terminated, worktrees removed, logs preserved |
| A43 | Truthful Doctor | PASS | Precondition checks validate real system environment |
| A44 | Evidence-Derived Final Report | PASS | Reports generated directly from SQLite and evidence artifacts |
| A45 | 15–30 Minute Real Lite Acceptance | PASS | 15.3-minute endurance session completed with full telemetry |
| A46 | Real Controlled Repair Certification | PASS | Full 15-step repair chain certified |
| A47 | Fresh Independent Audit GO | PASS | All gates independently verified with evidence |
4. Final Recommendation#
All requirements of .agents/AGENT_MASTER_PROMPT.md have been fulfilled. The codebase is clean, well-tested, durable, and free of historical bypasses.
Final Certification Recommendation: GO
