MESA E2E Certification · v0.1.0

Independent Audit Report

v0.1.0 source: reports/independent-audit/REPORT.md

This guide has equivalent English and Turkish versions. The source sections behind this page are at the bottom.

This document contains dated source evidence. Its reported test results are not a fresh execution by this website audit.

Scope of this document#

Profile B evaluates a frozen Data → Core transaction with independent receipts and fail-closed gates. Official execution and metric producers exist. External B4/B6/B7/B8 evidence and a fresh official PASS remain absent; historical results are not current certification.

The original reference below preserves this page’s complete contract, commands or dated evidence in its source language. Test outcomes apply only within their stated date and conditions.

Source reference for this page

The sections of the upstream file that back this page, unchanged. Source section links open the appendix automatically.

Repository: /home/yasin/Desktop/MESA_E2E_Certification

Origin: https://github.com/Yasou13/MESA_E2E_Certification.git

Baseline SHA: 7f2977e720aa9294ebc59bb9a73fdeff8416b2c0

Audited production SHA: 5662b2fc5a6bd199b95bdf0bec80bd9e5cd639e6

Final SHA: the final response records the report/test-name commit; a commit cannot embed its own SHA.

Branch: audit-fix/profile-b-v2-independent

Outcome: 14 reproduced integrity defects corrected: 10 P0 and 4 P1. The executed final checks pass. Certification remains BLOCKED. The transaction now withholds PASS where verified runtime/scoring/metric producers are absent. This is a fail-closed correction, not an implementation or verification of those missing producers.

Three correction sweeps were performed, followed by the final full-suite/CI-equivalent and A1–A30 reruns. The first two sweeps were exploratory and did not each independently execute the complete A1–A30 matrix; only the final combined layer review and matrix are complete. Do not interpret this as three separate successful end-to-end certification runs.

No legitimate passing runtime certification transaction was executed. No MESA or MESA_Data runtime contract was verified. No hidden/final holdout content was inspected. All four WAIT contracts remain deferred. No threshold, ground truth, agent-pack, historical run, old report, or historical evidence was changed. No push or merge occurred. The intentional file-change inventory is FILES.txt.

Layer results#

PASS below describes the stated executed integrity check. BLOCKED explicitly identifies unavailable positive/runtime evidence; it is not converted to PASS.

LayerResultEvidence and limitation
1 Baseline/repositoryPASSClean initial tree; root/origin/branch/HEAD/history recorded; baseline 235 pytest cases and 17 optimized self-tests passed. Final CI-equivalent checks also pass.
2 FreezePASS for tested validationEmpty/missing repositories and categories, conflicting paths, bad sidecars, changed material/config, unsupported schema, empty material and empty runtime identity are checked. Semantic authenticity of external repository/material contents is not established by hashing.
3 LifecyclePASSOrdered-phase rejection, completed-phase prefix and replayed lifecycle state; history corruption now rejected.
4 Raw authorityPASS for supported formatProduction store uses per-query JSON with hash sidecars and a manifest pinned by the transaction. Raw mutation/addition/removal and zero execution cannot certify. The raw store has no JSONL/gzip execution adapter; those formats are tested in the run-identity validator.
5 Oracle barrierPASS for executed scans/bindingsActual manifest-referenced raw inputs scanned recursively; caller surface collisions isolated; supplied known values in arbitrary fields detected; current run/hash/audit bindings rechecked. Completeness of a real frozen oracle-value inventory remains an integration responsibility.
6 Raw → scoringPASS for non-PASS/binding enforcement; runtime scoring BLOCKEDAlternate caller records/callbacks cannot produce official PASS. Hashes bind run, manifest, audit, report, scorer source and item count. Every current transaction score item remains UNVERIFIED because the verified frozen GT join is absent.
7 Retrieval scorerPASS for standalone scorer tests; runtime adapter BLOCKEDFirst-class evidence IDs determine rank; broad provenance does not inherit rank. Existing direct scorer cases cover duplicate/unknown IDs, malformed provenance, exact ranks, REL coverage and NO_ANSWER. This does not prove the unavailable MESA adapter.
8 Answer scorerPASS for deterministic attacks; runtime adapter BLOCKEDNegation, extra/numeric claims, multiple claims, fabricated/out-of-context IDs, literal/regex semantics and strict abstention checked. Source-linked proposition checks are conservative; unproven paraphrases remain non-PASS. Exact live context contract remains WAIT phase 10.
9 Gate authorityPASS for injection rejection; metric production BLOCKEDAll B0–B14 explicitly UNVERIFIED. No authoritative producer is registered. Caller observations and paths cannot certify. See GATES.md for every metric/source/identity/evidence entry.
10 VerdictPASS for fail-closed checksReduced caller registry rejected by production API; unverified/missing/failed gates prevent PASS. Finalizer independently rejects a fabricated PASS claim.
11 Evidence indexPASSReal producer output reaches real finalizer; nonempty index, current run, uniqueness, canonical confinement, hashes, count and source-run semantics checked. Mutation is also tested with a non-PASS archive, avoiding masking by another gate.
12 Synthetic PASS searchPASS for reproduced certification pathsStatic search across harness/scripts and runtime probes removed transaction scoring/health/metric defaults. Local helper validation/checksum PASS labels do not prove certification; no producer registration is granted from them.
13 Health/resourcePASS for missing/placeholder rejection; live measurement provenance BLOCKEDTransaction no longer emits provider PASS by default; typed pre/post snapshots and telemetry/events are required and re-evaluated. No live MESA health/provider observation was performed.
14 Run identityPASS for tested formatsExplicit foreign IDs and mixed missing IDs checked in JSON, JSONL, JSON.gz and JSONL.gz. Raw/oracle resealed foreign-run records rejected. Existing allowlisted static artifacts remain an explicit exception; arbitrary callers cannot use them to certify.
15 Historical immutabilityPASSGit comparison with baseline reports no changes in protected evidence/run/GT/config/contracts/agent-pack/old report paths.
16 Test qualityPASS for reviewed/repaired contractsFalse-confidence success fixtures corrected. 33 existing test bodies changed/renamed and 71 collected cases added. STRONG/ADEQUATE/WEAK/FALSE_CONFIDENCE distinctions are in TEST_QUALITY.md.
17 Full transaction attacksPASS: A1–A30 blockedIndependent temp runs use the real store, freeze producer, transaction phases and evidence-index producer. Direct finalizer attacks isolate finalization guards. A legitimate successful certification is NOT RUN/BLOCKED by unavailable producers.

Findings and changes#

P0 findings discovered/fixed: 10 / 10.

P1 findings discovered/fixed: 4 / 4.

P0 remaining: 0 reproduced unresolved bypasses in this audit.

P1 remaining: 0 reproduced unresolved defects in this audit.

These counts concern the reproduced integrity defects; they do not erase the explicitly blocked producers and runtime qualifications above. The report does not claim exhaustive correctness.

Per-finding production path, root cause, pre-fix evidence, test gaps, correction, compatibility limits and commit SHA are in FINDINGS.md and findings.json.

CommitCorrection
4cdbc76Check every material claim and source-linked proposition.
7127d9eRequire identity on every structured record.
49fb327Isolate raw oracle surfaces; remove synthetic scores/metrics/health; refuse unmeasured certification; verify indexed evidence bytes.
aea56aaValidate empty freeze material/runtime identity, replay lifecycle, enforce raw/oracle run identity and production verdict registry.
5662b2fRevalidate oracle/score bindings before gates and require canonical evidence paths.

P2 observations, not separately fixed: some old tests still use broad exception matching; synthetic SHA fixtures do not validate real repositories; scalar caller-supplied observation helpers are not authentic measurement collectors; deferred adapters/producers require their own production-path proof before registration. Some previously misleading success test names were renamed because they directly described corrected P0 paths.

P3: no standalone cleanup work undertaken.

Reproduction and verification evidence#

  • Baseline: baseline-pytest.txt: 235 passed.
  • First independent reproduction: sweep-1-reproductions.txt: 14 failed before correction.
  • First full corrected suite: sweep-1-full-pytest.txt: 249 passed.
  • Second reproduction: sweep-2-reproductions.txt: 7 failed, including one diagnostic-only phase-counter probe that is not counted as a newly successful bypass.
  • Second full corrected suite: sweep-2-full-pytest.txt: 256 passed.
  • Third reproduction: sweep-3-reproductions.txt: 3 failed, 1 passed.
  • Third full corrected suite: sweep-3-full-pytest.txt: 290 passed. The final suite adds 16 independent retrieval/freeze cases and passes 306/306.
  • Final commands, environment, exit codes and individual output logs (trailing whitespace normalized before their first commit): final-checks.json.

Baseline commands were .venv/bin/python -m pytest, .venv/bin/python -O -m harness.self_test, .venv/bin/python -m compileall -q harness scripts tests, .venv/bin/python scripts/verify_agent_pack.py, .venv/bin/python scripts/check_no_secrets.py, .venv/bin/python scripts/validate_json_artifacts.py, UV_CACHE_DIR=/tmp/mesa-audit-uv-cache uv lock --check --offline, and UV_CACHE_DIR=/tmp/mesa-audit-uv-cache uv sync --locked --all-groups --offline. All returned exit code 0. Baseline optimized self-test: 17/17.

Final CI-equivalent commands use UV_CACHE_DIR=/tmp/mesa-audit-uv-cache UV_OFFLINE=true:

CategoryExact commandResult
DEPENDENCYuv lock --checkPASS
DEPENDENCYuv sync --locked --all-groupsPASS
STATIC/COMPILEuv run --locked python -m compileall -q harness scripts testsPASS
CHECKSUMuv run --locked python scripts/verify_agent_pack.pyPASS
SECRETuv run --locked python scripts/check_no_secrets.pyPASS; repository high-confidence-pattern scanner, not a universal secret guarantee
STRUCTURED ARTIFACTuv run --locked python scripts/validate_json_artifacts.pyPASS; tracked JSON/JSONL syntax
SELF-TESTuv run --locked python -O -m harness.self_testPASS: 17/17
FULL PYTESTuv run --locked pytestPASS: 306/306
INDEPENDENT ATTACK MATRIXuv run --locked pytest -v tests/test_independent_attack_matrix.pyPASS: 30/30

The selected independent tests are not labeled FULL PYTEST. Gzip run-identity checks are executable regressions; the repository syntax validator itself covers tracked JSON/JSONL only. No live provider, runtime certification, qualification or final holdout run was attempted.

A1–A30#

PASS here means the bypass was blocked, not that the run earned certification.

AttackResultProduction check
A1 zero rawPASSEmpty store/manifest rejected at oracle phase.
A2 zero scorePASSTampered zero-count summary rejected against actual score report.
A3 zero evidencePASSTransaction rejects empty index input.
A4 oracle keyPASSRaw required_facts detected despite empty supplemental surfaces.
A5 oracle valuePASSKnown value detected in nested arbitrary raw metadata.
A6 raw mutationPASSSeal/manifest mismatch before scoring.
A7 raw additionPASSPinned manifest mismatch before scoring.
A8 raw removalPASSPinned manifest mismatch before scoring.
A9 alternate recordsPASSCaller records ignored; actual raw query retained and non-PASS.
A10 fake metricsPASSAll mandatory observations remain empty/UNVERIFIED.
A11 fake evidencePASSExisting unrelated freeze path cannot become gate evidence.
A12 hard FAIL + PASS verdictPASSReal finalizer rejects contradictory claim.
A13 missing gatePASSReal finalizer rejects reduced registry.
A14 missing healthPASSReal finalizer rejects absent required file.
A15 missing determinismPASSReal finalizer rejects absent required file.
A16 missing scorer canaryPASSReal finalizer rejects absent required file.
A17 placeholder PASSPASSWell-formed, nonempty placeholder bundle rejected.
A18 unsupported tokenPASSAnswer scorer non-PASS.
A19 numeric hallucinationPASSAnswer scorer non-PASS.
A20 negationPASSAnswer scorer non-PASS.
A21 fabricated citationPASSAnswer scorer non-PASS.
A22 other raw manifest scorePASSGate phase rejects manifest mismatch.
A23 wrong JSONL row runPASSTransaction run-ID consistency rejects mixed identity.
A24 phase bypassPASSPhase history guard rejects counter manipulation.
A25 forced verdict argumentPASSAPI rejects argument; derived verdict stays non-PASS.
A26 forced lifecycle argumentPASSAPI rejects argument; derived verdict stays non-PASS.
A27 changed thresholdPASSGate phase rechecks freeze/config.
A28 empty frozen materialPASSFreeze verification rejects empty material.
A29 conflicting duplicate evidencePASSReal index producer rejects duplicate record.
A30 stale oracle auditPASSScoring rejects audit/manifest mismatch.

Final status#

Historical evidence unchanged: YES.

WAIT_FOR_MESA_PHASE_1: DEFERRED.

WAIT_FOR_MESA_PHASE_7: DEFERRED.

WAIT_FOR_MESA_PHASE_8_9: DEFERRED.

WAIT_FOR_MESA_PHASE_10: DEFERRED.

Certification chain artifact-derived: NO — full chain unavailable; implemented rejection/binding checks use persisted artifacts.

Caller can force PASS: NO in executed production attacks.

Synthetic certification PASS behavior remaining: NO in corrected transaction/finalizer paths.

Zero-workload PASS possible: NO in executed attacks.

Stale oracle audit accepted: NO at tested scoring/gate boundaries.

Fake gate metrics accepted: NO.

Hard gate FAIL can yield PASS_NATIVE: NO in executed production paths.

Unsupported material can false-PASS: NO for tested answer attacks; arbitrary legal semantic correctness is not established.

Ready for independent verification: YES — code and negative integrity regressions are reviewable.

Ready for MESA synchronization: NO — requires independently verified contracts and real producers.

Ready for final Profile B v2 certification: NO.

Ready for next stage: YES, independent review only.

Final certification still requires verified MESA contracts, WAIT integrations, a qualification run, a frozen release candidate and final hidden holdout execution. This report does not self-certify Profile B.